Mr Nolan was driving his car when he saw an ice-cream van parked on the offside of the road in front of him.

There were also three cars parked on the opposite side of the road ahead of the van. He slowed almost to a standstill to allow an approaching car to pass. He then accelerated to about 15mph.

A young boy, aged five, ran out in front of Nolan’s moving car from between the parked cars and was struck by the moving vehicle.

At first instance, the Judge found that Mr Nolan could not have avoided striking the boy unless he had been travelling at less than 5mph. He therefore came to the conclusion that the car driver was not negligent.

On appeal, it was argued that Mr Nolan should have realised the serious risk of a child running across the road bearing in mind it was a sunny day and the attraction of the ice-cream van.

This case was appealed but the appeal was dismissed. It was agreed that it was a matter for the judge at first instance to determine what was a reasonable standard of care in all the circumstances of the case, and unless there was a good reason to differ from him, his decision should stand.

Related Articles

Pedestrian Law

Paramasivan v Wicks (2013)

Case Law Pedestrian Law
February 13, 2024

A 13 yr old child runs onto a road from between two parked cars and is hit by a passing motorist.

Pedestrian Law

Jackson v Murray (2015)

Case Law Pedestrian Law
February 13, 2024

A 13 year old girl is hit by a car following alighting from a school minibus and attempting to cross the road.

Pedestrian Law

McCreery v Letson and others (2015)

Case Law Pedestrian Law
February 13, 2024

A pedestrian is struck by a van after stepping out from behind a bus to cross the road.

Is it worth 5 minutes of your time?

A quick phone call allows us to ask you a few questions about what happened to you and determine whether we can help. 

This form collects your name and phone number so that we can contact you. Check out our Privacy Policy for more detail on how we store, process and protect your submitted data. If you choose not to consent, please use an alternative contact method shown on our Contact page.

Get in Touch

Name(Required)